Who Cleans the House: Choosing Your Own Hands or a Hired Cleaner

Cleaning is one of the household jobs that can be handed off without changing much about her day, but it also brings a new person into rooms she knows by heart. Deciding between your own hands and a hired cleaner is less about the task itself and more about the hours it takes, the people in the house, and the routine she counts on.

Local option: New Plan Care gives families in the St. Louis area in-home help so a parent can stay home: companionship, help with bathing and dressing, meals, and overnight care. Call (314) 405-0887.

Count what doing it yourself costs in hours

For one week, write down every cleaning session: the start time, the length, the rooms, and where she was while you worked. You will see the real cost. Often the hardest part is not the scrubbing but the stretches when you are out of sight of her, or the minutes spent moving between rooms. Those are the minutes a hired cleaner can cover, and they are also the minutes your own hands may be best kept for.

Split the tasks by where she needs you

Do not treat cleaning as one job. Split it into tasks: floors, bathrooms, dusting, laundry, windows, and kitchen counters. Mark which tasks you can do in the same room she is in, and which ones would take you away from her. A cleaner is most useful for the tasks that would otherwise pull you out of sight. Dusting in the room where you are already sitting with her may be easy to keep for yourself.

Ask the questions before you book

Ask whether the same person comes each time, because a familiar face matters to her. Ask what time they arrive and whether a daytime slot is available. Ask how they screen staff, whether they check references, and who holds a key and how it is signed out. Ask for the company's insurance paper in writing. Tell them which rooms she uses most and which furniture stays where it is, and ask them to tell you if something is out of place rather than quietly moving it back.

Keep medicine off the cleaning list

Medicine bottles, pill boxes, and any dosing task stay with the family, her doctor, and her pharmacist. Write that on the cleaning list in plain words, and keep her medicine in a place a cleaner has no reason to open. A cleaner can wipe the counter around the bottles, but should not sort, move, or manage them.

Decide with the week's tally in hand

Once you have the tally, the choice gets simpler. If your own cleaning takes most of your free hours and leaves her alone in the rooms where she is most unsettled, hire the tasks that take you away from her. If the cleaning is short and you enjoy the rhythm of it, keep one small weekly task yourself and hire the rest. Either way, tell her what is happening in simple words, such as that the cleaner is coming in the morning, and keep her day as steady as you can.

If you are building the whole evening plan around these choices, begin with Start Here: Dusk to Morning, in Order.